Mar 20, 2012

Atrocities occur in  wars. This is an observation, not an excuse. And they become more likely the longer a soldier is in combat. War is brutal and it brutalizes the souls of warriors. Some resist the brutalization better than others, but no one can see death that often and not be changed. Just as important, the enemy is dehumanized. You cannot fight and fear him for years and not come to see him as someone alien to you. Even worse, when the enemy and the population are difficult to distinguish, as is the case in a counterinsurgency, the fear and rage extends to everyone. 


Mar 5, 2012

There is another secret to American success -- both in controlling the oceans and taking advantage of European failures -- that lies in an often-misunderstood economic structure called Bretton Woods. Even before World War II ended, the United States had leveraged its position as the largest economy and military to convince all of the Western allies -- most of whose governments were in exile at the time -- to sign onto the Bretton Woods accords. The states committed to the formation of the International Monetary Fund and World Bank to assist with the expected post-War reconstruction. Considering the general destitution of Western Europe at the time, this, in essence, was a U.S. commitment to finance if not outright fund that reconstruction. Because of that, the U.S. dollar was the obvious and only choice to serve as the global currency.

But Bretton Woods was about more than currency regimes and international institutions; its deeper purpose lay in two other features that are often overlooked. The United States would open its markets to participating states' exports while not requiring reciprocal access for its own. In exchange, participating states would grant the United States deference in the crafting of security policy. NATO quickly emerged as the organization through which this policy was pursued.

Global history from 1500 to 1945 is a lengthy treatise of increasing contact and conflict among a series of great regional powers. Some of these powers achieved supra-regional empires, with the Spanish, French and English being the most obvious. Several regional powers -- Austria, Germany, Ottoman Turkey and Japan -- also succeeded in extending their writ over huge tracts of territory during parts of this period. And several secondary powers -- the Netherlands, Poland, China and Portugal -- had periods of relative strength. Yet the two world wars massively devastated all of these powers. No battles were fought in the mainland United States. Not a single American factory was ever bombed. Alone among the world's powers in 1945, the United States was not only functional but thriving.

Feb 28, 2012

Envisioning Technology | Envisioning emerging technology for 2012 and beyond 

http://envisioningtech.com/

Feb 21, 2012

The evolution of geopolitics is cyclical. Powers rise, fall and shift. Changes occur in every generation in an unending ballet. However, the period between 1989 and 1991 was unique in that a long cycle of human history spanning hundreds of years ended, and with it a shorter cycle also came to a close. The world is still reverberating from the events of that period. 

On Dec. 25, 1991, an epoch ended. On that day the Soviet Union collapsed, and for the first time in almost 500 years no European power was a global power, meaning no European state integrated economic, military and political power on a global scale. What began in 1492 with Europe smashing its way into the world and creating a global imperial system had ended. For five centuries, one European power or another had dominated the world, whether Portugal, Spain, France, England or the Soviet Union. Even the lesser European powers at the time had some degree of global influence. 

After 1991 the only global power left was the United States, which produced about 25 percent of the world's gross domestic product (GDP) each year and dominated the oceans. Never before had the United States been the dominant global power. Prior to World War II, American power had been growing from its place at the margins of the international system, but it was emerging on a multipolar stage. After World War II, it found itself in a bipolar world, facing off with the Soviet Union in a struggle in which American victory was hardly a foregone conclusion. 

The United States has been the unchallenged global power for 20 years, but its ascendancy has left it off-balance for most of this time, and imbalance has been the fundamental characteristic of the global system in the past generation. Unprepared institutionally or psychologically for its position, the United States has swung from an excessive optimism in the 1990s that held that significant conflict was at an end to the wars against militant Islam after 9/11, wars that the United States could not avoid but also could not integrate into a multilayered global strategy. When the only global power becomes obsessed with a single region, the entire world is unbalanced. Imbalance remains the defining characteristic of the global system today. 

Feb 17, 2012

http://walt.foreignpolicy.com/posts/2012/02/16/xi_jipings_overhyped_visit

First, as a good realist, I think that the basic state of Sino-American relations will be driven more by balances of power and configurations of interest than by the personalities of individual leaders. As I've noted before, if China continues to grow more powerful, Bejing and Washington will view each other with an increasingly wary eye and are likely to find more issues about which to conflict. A serious security competition -- especially in East Asia -- will be likely (which does not mean that war is inevitable or even likely, by the way). Again assuming China's continued ascent, I'm guessing this will occur no matter who is in power in each country.

Feb 10, 2012

No one seriously denies that the state has a role to play in economic life. The question is what that role should be and how it can be performed in ways that simultaneously enhance economic efficiency and minimize the kind of rent-seeking behavior -- "corruption" in all its shapes and forms -- that tends to arise wherever the public and private sectors meet.

We are all state capitalists now -- and we have been for over a century, ever since the modern state began its steady growth in the late 19th century, when Adolph Wagner first formulated his law of rising state expenditures. But there are myriad forms of state capitalism, from the enlightened autocracy of Singapore to the dysfunctional tyranny of Zimbabwe, from the egalitarian nanny state of Denmark to the individualist's paradise that is Ron Paul's Texas.

The real contest of our time is not between a state-capitalist China and a market-capitalist America, with Europe somewhere in the middle. It is a contest that goes on within all three regions as we all struggle to strike the right balance between the economic institutions that generate wealth and the political institutions that regulate and redistribute it.

The character of this century -- whether it is "post-American," Chinese, or something none of us yet expects -- will be determined by which political system gets that balance right.

Feb 9, 2012

Reclaiming the Republic

republic
Picture Credit: penguin.com
Acclaimed author Lawrence Lessig denounces institutions corrupted by moneyed interests - Congress, accounting, financial services, healthcare, academics and the media. He compares institutional corruption with a disease for which the body cannot develop a sufficient immune response. Slowly but surely, corruption as an invidious, systemic wrong destroys the body politic. In this Boston-Review interview, Lessig presents concrete solutions to what he believes to be one of the most dangerous forms of corruption, namely the US campaign-finance system.   
http://www.globalpolicy.org/globalization/globalization-of-politics/general-analysis-on-globalization-of-politics/51252-reclaiming-the-republic-.html?itemid=id#651

the U.S. Navy Plan to End National Sovereignty As We Know It

drones2
Picture Credit: 
operationbrokensilence.org

The US military has positioned many drone bases “offshore,” making it easier for drones to cross nation-state boundaries. It has also increased its CIA backed special operations force, which often uses drones. The merge of special operations forces with drone technology has hidden US military operations from public scrutiny. Allowing US drones to cross boundaries is a step towards establishing a free reigning and literally dehumanized US military empire.

http://www.globalpolicy.org/nations-a-states/general-analysis-on-states-and-their-future/51257-offshore-everywhere-how-drones-special-operations-forces-and-the-us-navy-plan-to-end-national-sovereignty-as-we-know-it.html?itemid=id#708

Jan 28, 2012

 

CEO and Managing Director, Intellectual Ventures; Co-Author (with Bill Gates), The Road Ahead; Author, Modernist Cuisine

The Scientific Method—An Explanation For Explanations

Humans are a story telling species. Throughout history we have told stories to each other and ourselves as one of the ways to understand the world around us. Every culture has its creation myth for how the universe came to be, but the stories do not stop at the big picture view; other stories discuss every aspect of the world around us. We humans are chatterboxes and we just can't resist telling a story about just about everything.

However compelling and entertaining these stories may be, they fall short of being explanations because in the end all they are is stories. For every story you can tell a different variation, or a different ending, without giving reason to choose between them. If you are skeptical or try to test the veracity of these stories you'll typically find most such stories wanting. One approach to this is forbid skeptical inquiry, branding it as heresy. This meme is so compelling that it was independently developed by cultures around the globes; it is the origin of religion—a set of stories about the world that must be accepted on faith, and never questioned.

Somewhere along the line a very different meme got started. Instead of forbidding inquiry into stories about the world people tried the other extreme of encouraging continual questioning. Stories about aspect of the world can be questioned skeptically, and tested with observations and experiments. If the story survives the tests then provisionally at least one can accept it as something more than a mere story; it is a theory that has real explanatory power. It will never be more than a provisional explanation—we can never let down our skeptical guard—but these provisional explanations can be very useful. We call this process of making and vetting stories the scientific method.

For me, the scientific method is the ultimate elegant explanation. Indeed it is the ultimate foundation for anything worthy of the name "explanation". It makes no sense to talk about explanations without having a process for deciding which are right and which are wrong, and in a broad sense that is what the scientific method is about. All of the other wonderful explanations celebrated here owe their origin and credibility to the process by which they are verified—the scientific method.

This seems quite obvious to us now, but it took many thousands of years for people to develop the scientific method to a point where they could use it to build useful theories about the world. It was not, a priori, obvious that such a method would work. At one extreme, creation myths discuss the origin of the universe, and for thousands of years one could take the position that this will never be more than a story—how can humans ever figure out something that complicated and distant in space and time? It would be a bold bet to say that people reasoning with the scientific method could solve that puzzle.

Well, it has taken us a while but by now enormous amounts are known about the composition of stars and galaxies and how the universe came to be. There are still gaps in our knowledge (and our skepticism will never stop), but we've made a lot of progress on cosmology and many other problems. Indeed we know more about the composition of distant stars than many questions about things here on earth. The scientific method has not conquered all great questions - other issues remain illusive, but the spirit of the scientific method is that one does shrink from the unknown. It is OK to say that we have no useful story for everything we are curious about, and we comfort ourselves that at some point in the future new explanations will fill the gaps in our current knowledge, as often raise new questions that highlight new gaps.

It's hard to overestimate the importance of the scientific method. Human culture contains much more than science—but science is the part that actually works—the rest is just stories. The rationally based inquiry the scientific method enables is what has given us science and technology and vastly different lifestyles than those of our hunter-gatherers ancestors. In some sense it is analogous to evolution. The sum of millions of small mutations separate us from single celled like blue-green algae. Each had to survive the test of selection and work better than the previous state in the sense of biological fitness. Human knowledge is the accumulation of millions of stories-that-work, each of which had to survive the test of the scientific method, matching observation and experiment more than the predecessors. Both evolution and science have taken us a long way, but looking forward it is clear that science will take us much farther. 

Jan 27, 2012

American-Chinese relations have long contained elements of rivalry and co-operation. But, increasingly, the rival elements are coming to the fore. This is not yet a new cold war. However, the state of relations between the United States and China -- the sole superpower and its only plausible rival -- are likely to set the tone for international politics in the coming decade.

In fact, the increasing rivalry between Washington and Beijing is an important contributor to the third major manifestation of the spread of zero-sum logic through the international system -- the increasing deadlock in multilateral diplomacy, from the World Trade Organization (WTO) to climate-change negotiations to the G-20's stalled efforts at global financial regulation.

Jan 20, 2012

The authors make a compelling case for optimism. We are introduced to dozens of innovators and industry captains making tremendous strides in healthcare, agriculture, energy, and other fields: Dean Kamen’s “Slingshot,” a technology that can transform polluted water, salt water, or even raw sewage into incredibly high-quality drinking water for less than one cent a liter; the Qualcomm Tricorder X-Prize, which promises a low-cost, handheld medical device that allows anyone to diagnose themself better than a board-certified doctor; and Dickson Despommier’s “vertical farms,” which replace traditional agriculture with a system that uses 80 percent less land, 90 percent less water, and 100 percent fewer pesticides, with zero transportation costs.

Jan 18, 2012

The list of powers acquired by the U.S. government since 9/11 puts us in rather troubling company. 

Assassination of U.S. citizens 

Indefinite detention 
Arbitrary justice 
Warrantless searches 
Secret evidence 
War crimes 
Secret court 
Immunity from judicial review 
Continual monitoring of citizens 
Extraordinary renditions 


(read the whole article) 

The Washington Post had this article yesterday. 10 reasons the U.S. is no longer the land of the free. Law professor Jonathan Turley began this way:

Jan 12, 2012

Those risks perceived by survey respondents to be of greatest systemic importance. For risk-related planning, Centres of Gravity should serve as focal points to guide strategic interventions.

The 2012 Centres of Gravity are:

- Chronic fiscal imbalances (economic)

- Greenhouse gas emissions (environmental)

- Global governance failure (geopolitical)

- Unsustainable population growth (societal)

- Critical systems failure (technological)

Jan 11, 2012

China, invariably mentioned as America's prospective successor, has an impressive imperial lineage and a strategic tradition of carefully calibrated patience, both of which have been critical to its overwhelmingly successful, several-thousand-year-long history. China thus prudently accepts the existing international system, even if it does not view the prevailing hierarchy as permanent. It recognizes that success depends not on the system's dramatic collapse but on its evolution toward a gradual redistribution of power. Moreover, the basic reality is that China is not yet ready to assume in full America's role in the world. Beijing's leaders themselves have repeatedly emphasized that on every important measure of development, wealth, and power, China will still be a modernizing and developing state several decades from now, significantly behind not only the United States but also Europe and Japan in the major per capita indices of modernity and national power. Accordingly, Chinese leaders have been restrained in laying any overt claims to global leadership.

The leaders of the world's second-rank powers, among them India, Japan, Russia, and some European countries, are already assessing the potential impact of U.S. decline on their respective national interests. The Japanese, fearful of an assertive China dominating the Asian mainland, may be thinking of closer links with Europe. Leaders in India and Japan may be considering closer political and even military cooperation in case America falters and China rises. Russia, while perhaps engaging in wishful thinking (even schadenfreude) about America's uncertain prospects, will almost certainly have its eye on the independent states of the former Soviet Union. Europe, not yet cohesive, would likely be pulled in several directions: Germany and Italy toward Russia because of commercial interests, France and insecure Central Europe in favor of a politically tighter European Union, and Britain toward manipulating a balance within the EU while preserving its special relationship with a declining United States. Others may move more rapidly to carve out their own regional spheres: Turkey in the area of the old Ottoman Empire, Brazil in the Southern Hemisphere, and so forth. None of these countries, however, will have the requisite combination of economic, financial, technological, and military power even to consider inheriting America's leading role.

Dec 27, 2011

Experts are making predictions for 2012 in a wide variety of technology, business, and economics areas. Here’s our pick of the most interesting. – Ed.

Marc Andreessen: Predictions for 2012 (and beyond), CNET

5 gadget predictions for 2012, ComputerWeekly

Gartner Predicts 2012, Gartner, Inc.

Five predictions for the communications world in 2012, The Guardian

Worldwide System Infrastructure Software 2012 Top 10 Predictions, IDC

Security Predictions for 2012, InfoWorld

6 Crazy Tech Predictions for 2012, Mashable

12 predictions for 2012, NESTA (National Endowment for Science Technology and the Arts)

Smart Guide 2012: 10 ideas you’ll want to understand, New Scientist

Five big data predictions for 2012, O’Reilly Radar

Tech highlights of 2011. Predictions for 2012, Smarter Computing Blog

The Definitive Guide To HTML5: 14 Predictions For 2012, TechCrunch

Predictions for 2012: economic recovery, The Telegraph

Four Personal Finance Technology Trends for 2012, Time Techland

Dec 14, 2011

Output shifts

Despite two decades of outsourcing and globalisation, the US remains the world’s largest manufacturer in 2009. However, its share of world value-added in manufacturing declined from around 22.7% of the total in 1990 to less than 20% in 2009. China’s share rose from a minute 2.7% to 17.5% over the same period, taking over Japan, hitherto the world’s second largest manufacture, whose share dropped from 17.7% to 11.4% over the two decades.

China’s increase was a fillip to the share of emerging markets in general,  with BRIIC countries (which as well as China include Brazil, Russia, India, Indonesia and South Africa) accounting for a quarter of value-added in manufacturing in 2009 compared with less than 10% in 1990.

This is in contrast with the fall in the share of several other OECD countries has also fallen, notably in Germany by three percentage points to just over 6% of the total. The EU now accounts for only 17.5%. Two OECD countries that saw slight increases include Australia, whose share edged up to 1% of the total, as it gained from the Asian boom, and Mexico, whose share reached 1.8%, up from 1.3%, reflected this economy’s emerging status.

Markets and state-managed institutions are not always well suited to managing common-pool resources, such as water catchments, river fisheries or nearby pasture lands. Resources have to be managed sustainably over time, and market prices and government rules might not be able to deliver the most effective solutions.

Dec 13, 2011

As a strategic power that is intent on rivaling the United States, China is naturally  an economic power with a GNP that is projected to surpass that of the United States at the nominal level in 2025.  By dint of the simple fact that it has become the second greatest economic power in the world, China has seen its economic relations with the other BRICS significantly increase. China is the primary trade partner of Brazil, India, and South Africa. The interdependence among BRICS is  thereby considerably deepening. This development should be interpreted with caution, however. The closer economic ties among the BRICS have more to do with additional bilateral agreements than with any integration among these countries. For all the BRICS, the region remains the preferred level for economic integration processes.

Dec 7, 2011

Forecasting Asia's Growing Pains

Asia’s growth will strain the resources of the entire globe by mid-century, according to Charles Morrison, president of the East-West Center. Morrison told business leaders at an Asia-Pacific Business Symposium that, by 2050, Asia will own more than half the world’s automobiles and more than half of global GDP.

With all the development come vulnerabilities. Asia’s most rapidly growing cities will be more susceptible to natural and human-made disasters, Morrison warned. Also, large human and animal populations living close together raises the risks of new disease pandemics.

Meanwhile, by 2050, 40% of Japan’s population will be over 60 years old, and less than 9% will be younger than 15, creating a future demographic disaster as fewer young people will be able to support their elders. And environmentally, water scarcities already afflict parts of Asia due to increased farm and livestock production.

“There are uncertainties about how to handle the enormous challenges Asian countries face,“ said Morrison, who called for more dialogue among the region’s nations.

Nov 30, 2011

Chinese Ratings Agency Threatens US with New Debt Downgrade - (Guardian - November 11, 2011)
The head of China's biggest ratings agency, Dagong Global Credit Rating, is warning that it may downgrade the US's sovereign debt rating again because of Washington's failure to tackle the federal budget deficit. Dagong, which has maintained a pessimistic outlook on US fiscal policy, has been leading the charge to downgrade US debt over the last 12 months, lowering the US rating from AA to A+ a year ago. 

In 1980, before the War on Drugs became big business and for-profit corporations started taking over the running of prisons, there were 12,300 women incarcerated in the United States. By 2008, that number had grown to 207,700. The rate of increase between 1995 and 2008 alone was a staggering 203%.

The average farmer in Japan is now 65.8 years old and that figure is rising steadily - but a wave of Japanese young people are becoming attracted to farming and a rural lifestyle. 

Nov 27, 2011

More specifically, the report echoes other forecasts (see CSS’s Strategic Trends 2011) in predicting a redistribution of wealth and economic power “roughly from West to East” with “no other countries projected to rise to the level of China, India or Russia” or “match their individual global clout.”  Complementing this trend will be the sustained political pressures caused by economic growth and a growing competition over strategic resources, to include energy, water and food.  In terms of energy, viable technological alternatives to hydrocarbons may exist by 2025, but it is questionable if the incentives to adopt them on a wide enough scale will exist by then. In turn, terrorism, though less widespread than now, will become more technologically sophisticated and dangerous.  The use by terrorists groups of advanced tactical weapons will become more common and the availability of biological, radiological and chemical weapons will grow.  In fact, the chances of a hostile nuclear detonation, terrorist or otherwise, “though remaining very low,” will nevertheless increase.   

Unsurprisingly, the report further suggests that the big losers of 2025 will be Europe and Japan, where ageing populations and inadequate immigration policies will continue to undercut economic growth and capabilities.  In the U.S., where birth rates are higher, the effect will be less severe and will most likely be offset by immigration.  

Global Trends 2025 believes that the international system will become genuinely multipolar in the coming years.  Although multipolar systems tend to be prone to conflict, the report argues that by 2025 the world will most likely resemble the 19thcentury, with its familiar arms races, territorial expansionism and military rivalries. This system-wide evolution, however, will not represent a simple return to the past. On the contrary, multiple actors and competing sources of political identity will make for an international order that is far more dynamic and complex than the one that led to the death of five tottering empires in 1914-1918.

Recommended Reading

“Africa: Will the Continent Break Through,” in Juggernaut: How the Rise of Developing Countries Is Reshaping the World Economy; Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2011

The Futures Report 2011 ; Global Futures and Foresight, 2011

World Order in 2050 ; Carnegie Endowment for International Peace, 2010

Will the Global Crisis Lead to Global Transformations?; Grinin, Leonid ; Korotayev, Andrey: Journal of Globalization Studies, 2010

The Global Future and Its Policy Implications: Views from Leading Thinkers of Five Continents ; Atlantic Council of the United States, 2009

The Global Future and Its Policy Implications: The Views from Johannesburg, Lagos and Cairo; Atlantic Council of the United States, 2009

Global Risks 2008 ; World Economic Forum, 2008

Strategic Challenges ; Institute for National Strategic Studies, 2008

Emerging Threats in the 21st Century - Strategic Foresight and Warning ; Center for Security Studies, 2007

The World in 2030: Regional Trends ; Il Centro Militare di Studi Strategici, 2007

Global Demography: Face, Force and Future ; World Demographic Association, 2006

Global Futures and Implications for US Basing ; Atlantic Council of the United States, 2005

Globalization and Future Architectures: Mapping the Global Future 2020 Project ; Chatham House, 2005

Mapping the Global Future ; National Intelligence Council, 2004

Both STRATFOR andStrategic Trends 2011 are convinced that the U.S. should maintain its regional influence in the short term, but the continued diversification of its energy supplies beyond the Middle East, coupled with a general decline in the threat of jihadist terrorism, might increasingly permit Washington to divert its attention to Asia Pacific, where it will confront the growing influence of China. Indeed, the United States may even divert attention to issues that are closer to home. In the case of Mexico, the United States has a near-neighbor that is, in the opinion of many, rapidly becoming a narco-state. But, as Strategic Trends 2011 points outs, ‘divergence’ throughout the international system may complicate the United States’ attempts to lead a coalition to break the narcotics-insecurity cycle.

Nov 26, 2011

Beginning with the 18th century, we have had a slew of thinkers who recurrently make “economic interdependence” arguments against war. One prominent example of this type of analyst was Sir Norman Angell, who later received the Noble Peace Prize for his anti-war work early in the 20th century. Prior to World War I, Angell published "The Great Illusion," which basically argued that the best way to discourage states from attacking each other was to so entangle their financial fates together that an attack by one against the other would constitute nothing less than economic suicide. More specifically, here's how Angell put it in the 1913 version of his famous text:

From a governance perspective, the management of multi-level complexity imparts considerable challenges. Overall, this period has dispersed power, most notably away from nation states. Embedded in a world complete with interdependencies, transnational phenomena and accelerated complexity, nation states have diminished capacity to mobilize and control physical (and virtual) borders, communication and financial systems, and the movement of goods and people. In sum, static, state-centric models of government are poorly equipped to handle this environment as they are predominantly inflexible – hindered by hierarchy and bureaucratic structures that limit the flow of information, engagement of multiple actors, and ability to change and adapt quickly.

In addition, system behavior is most troubling for the field of security if cascades and surprise effects are combined. Cascade effects are those that produce a chain of events that cross geography, time, and systems. Such effects are common in more interconnected, interdependent (referred to as tightly coupled) systems. Surprise effects are unexpected, but also truly unknowable events that arise out of interactions between agents and the negative and positive feedback loops produced through this interaction.

Using the complexity prism can help to understand the dynamics of today’s world which has become increasingly characterized by the non-linearity between cause and effect. Within the last 20 years alone, we have seen how globalization has brought online new relationships, influences, exchanges, and advances. Transformative changes in technology coupled with rampant growth in interconnectivity have created a world where societal and technical networks are continuously multiplying, increasing interactions across geographical space, time, and systems. With this, the role of non-state actors within the international system has grown markedly. This is evident when examining the proliferation and characteristics of dark networks.

Also, large systems with many components have the tendency to evolve into a poised and highly imbalanced “critical” state where minor disturbances may lead to events, called avalanches. This means that complex systems tend to adapt to, or are themselves on, the edge of chaos and most of the changes take place through catastrophic events rather than by following a smooth gradual path. The new path the system will take cannot be predicted and controlled before it is taken. Due to this emergent behavior, the complex system cannot be understood by reducing it to its parts; moreover, the behavior we are interested in evaporates when we try to reduce the system to a simpler, better-understood one.

Chaos and Complexity Studies

The precursor of complexity thinking is the investigation of dynamic systems. Very simply put, a system is a set of mutually dependent components or variables. Each component in the system stands in interrelation with every other component in the set and also in interaction with the system environment. In other words, the components interact with each other within the system’s boundaries to function as a whole to perform a task. Three types of systems exist: 

  • Ordered systems are those that are structured around a set of rules or laws that contain clear patterns where reliable outcomes can be determined. They are characterized by stability and discernible cause-and-effect relationships.
  • Complex (adaptive) systems incorporate a number of variables that simultaneously play many different roles in the system’s evolution and following many different laws of behavior. These systems are non-linear and potentially volatile. Their behavior can only be discovered by studying how these elements interact and how the system adapts and changes throughout time.
  • Chaotic systems are turbulent complex systems in transition to a different order. The relationships between cause and effect are impossible to determine because they shift constantly and no manageable patterns exist. No medium to long-term prediction whatsoever is possible.

The study of chaotic and complex systems has created a large and growing field of complexity science. While a variety of disciplines have used this analytical and theoretical prism, it has been particularly popular within the natural and, increasingly, social sciences. This trend points to the fact that complexity studies are applicable to all kinds of systems, regardless of their size or nature, like technological (sub-) systems, societal phenomena or the international political system.

In the post-Cold War era, stable and narrow security conceptions were broadened and deepened. Paralleled by discussions on moral necessities, western security policies were expanded to include political, societal, economic and environmental issues. As a result, the referent object of security was extended to groups, individuals, but also on inanimate objects such as technical infrastructure systems. At the same time, the notion of threat, understood as a problem that is deliberately created by one security actor for another, was losing saliency in many parts of the world. Several of the new challenges that security policy started to focus on in the post-Cold War world – global health issues, financial stability, critical infrastructure protection, but also terrorism to some extent – seemed much better captured by the concept of risk.

During the Cold War, the two superpowers combined geopolitical objectives with military capabilities that included weapons of mass destruction and the means to deliver them over intercontinental distances. Security threats were thus directly linked to military capabilities and arose mainly from the aggressive intentions of the other powerful actor in the international system. Although there were numerous strategic surprises during the Cold War, the ability to monitor each superpower’s strategic and military posture created a sense of certainty through calculability. To identify the level of threat, one looked at the capability of the enemy and their intent or motivation, in addition to one’s own vulnerability.

From a western perspective, there was not always agreement on the exact nature of the Soviet threat. The debate, however, evolved around the threat in terms of what could be measured; in other words, the threat in the form of actor, intention and capability was known or at least knowable. In addition, there was a belief that it was possible to defeat the threat and achieve security through known measures. The concept of deterrence in particular – which refers to the attempt to create risks so high in comparison to a possible gain that opponents refrain from engaging in a certain policy or action – existed as a credible option to prevent the threat from being enacted.

Using the controversy surrounding Iran's nuclear program as an example, this ISN multimedia feature illustrates how forecasts can be employed to serve the distinct interests of policymakers.

Despite forecasting’s dangers, however, the fact is that we now operate in a world defined by five domains (air, land, sea, space and cyberspace) and within a context defined by universal and instantaneous time. We therefore need all the “tilts” in the right directions we can get. We need to avoid being caught flat-footed. In other words, we need help not to react to events, but to anticipate and perhaps even shape them. International relations have always been complicated because of this desired shaping function. Well, that problem has only gotten worse over the last 20 years. 

Recent academic research suggests that economists with a proven track record in predicting ‘extreme’ events like recessions actually have the worst overall forecasting reputation. But this problem is not unique to economists, of course. For example, Philip Tetlock, in his ‘Expert Political Judgment’, analyzed more than 80,000 political predictions made over two decades. As in the case of the economists, expert political opinion fared no better than chance did. That’s right, chance.

The Conference Board has just published its Global Economic Outlook 2012 report and it projects a 6.6 percent growth rate for China from 2013-2016 and then an average of 3.5 percent per year between 2017 and 2025. Aren’t these numbers, which are shared by others, a harbinger of a bumpy ‘road’ ahead if nothing else?

 The 2010-2020 decade, for example, will see a reversal of the centuries-old trend of population growth driving economic relations. An ageing global population will strain, if not outright challenge, the economic structures and financial arrangements that have historically assumed that people would have shorter “non-productive” lives. The social and financial costs of this imbalance will have the most profound impact on the developed world as well as emerging countries like China and India. As a result, states will have to rely upon immigration from a new tranche of developing countries to compensate for irregularities and shortages in their labor markets.

The second road is a Multipolar World defined by a traditional order built around major nation-states. Nationalism once again exerts itself as a primal force in global affairs, with America and the West challenged by a rising Russia, Iran, India, Turkey and Brazil. This new multipolar arrangement would be global in scope and make for the empowerment of states long regarded by the West as barely capable of organizing themselves. New and improbable-sounding alliances would form -- between Russia and Turkey, and between Brazil and Iran, say. National 'spheres of influence' might have to be recognized, making life unhappy for the small nations of the planet. Should Europe recover its lost will to power, it could be a major player in such a world -- otherwise it risks being dominated by the others. As in the 19th century, peace in a multipolar world would hinge on a balance of power maintained by the biggest players at the point of a gun.

The third road is a Chinese Century. This would be proof of the proposition that the world, after all, does need a dominant player, a global rule maker, to ensure stability. If debt-ridden, imperially over-extended America can't do the job, then China, destined to become the world's largest economy, might have to step in. The world's clocks would be set on Beijing time; the yuan would supplant the dollar as the globe's reserve currency. America would be humbled but not necessarily miserable. The pragmatic Chinese aim mainly to enrich themselves, which augurs for the preservation of a global trading system in which the U.S. can participate.

The fifth road is a universal civilization leading to global government. The journey would be a creepy-crawl of an organic kind. The globalization of finance, already an economic reality, might lead naturally to a global financial sheriff. The globalization of ecological problems, like the warming of the planet, might lead to a global environmental regulator. A universal legal system might evolve to address matters like intellectual property rights. The new rulers of the world would be a global cosmopolitan elite -- the 'superclass' that now exists in embryonic form, gathering in places like Davos. Global government would be an invitation for utopian thinkers to impose their ideas on the planet -- but the superclass is actually a diverse one of contrasting ideologies. There might be two main parties -- a party of the grand planners, but also a party of market-oriented libertarian types, reflecting the division that now exists among globalists.

Nov 25, 2011

Arguments that support future forecasting can be separated into two distinct categories. First, such forecasting can represent a sincere attempt to anticipate conditions or events, and thereby not be caught “flat-footed” when they appear. Forecasting, in other words, attempts to think the unthinkable, prepare for the inevitable and control the controllable. Its utility is that it helps you rationalize and shape political strategies, as well as articulate and integrate these strategies into effective policies. Second, future forecasting can also serve educational, polemical, propagandistic or ideological ends. Now, instrumentalizing forecasting in this way can obviously have positive and negative consequences. On the positive side, forecasters can use their prognostications to publicize what they think are underappreciated dangers or potential threats. They can, in short, use their forecasts to educate others and better shape their expectations of future developments. On the more dubious side, those who practice future forecasting can tailor their predictions to ‘label’ threats and risks, for example, to promote more private interests and agendas.

Nov 22, 2011

These changes, of course, don’t remove the CIA from the assassination business or establish a definitive end date for the drone war. But the logic of drone technology – and its rapid proliferation – will soon prompt a more radical rethink. After all, the Pentagon wanted the United States to abide by the Geneva Conventions not because of a sudden conversion to human rights advocacy, but because of a fear of what other countries might do to U.S. soldiers. And U.S. officials eventually came to understand the usefulness of arms control not out of a commitment to world peace, but because the Soviet Union had acquired a sizable and quite dangerous arsenal of its own.

Today, the United States maintains a near monopoly on military drone technology, with only Israel and Britain also deploying these systems. But the landscape is rapidly changing. As David Cortright at the University of Notre Dame points out, more than 50 countries are developing or buying drone systems, including China and Iran, and even non-state actors want in on the business. The United States is now using drones to patrol borders and collect information about Mexican narcotraffickers. U.S. law enforcement agencies are also eager to use the technology against criminals on U.S. soil, withTexas sheriffs leading the way. Unmanned drones are already used in Japan, Australia, and other countries for such civilian activities as crop dusting and lifeguarding.

Nov 21, 2011

The End of Population Growth - (Nation of Change - October 31, 2011)
"[I]t is likely that world population will peak at nine billion in the 2050's, a half-century sooner than generally anticipated, followed by a sharp decline." Most countries conducted their national population census last year, and the data suggest that fertility rates are plunging in most of them. Birth rates have been low in developed countries for some time, but now they are falling rapidly in the majority of developing countries. Chinese, Russians, and Brazilians are no longer replacing themselves, while Indians are having far fewer children. Indeed, global fertility will fall to the replacement rate in a little more than a decade. Population may keep growing until mid-century, owing to rising longevity, but, reproductively speaking, our species should no longer be expanding. 

Nov 20, 2011

The end of the Cold War indicated  the end of the bipolar structure, both politically and economically, but the shift towards multipolarity occurred only in the economic field. On the political and military field, instead, the trend has been towards the hegemony of the United States.

Nov 18, 2011

This is a problem for everyone, rich and poor, because international evidence suggests that more equal economies grow faster. In fact, the historical evidence for the Americas, compiled in 2005 by economists Stanley Engerman and the late Kenneth Sokoloff of the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER) suggests that an early source of wealth in the American Northeast was a colonial farming system based around small landholders that encouraged equality and the provision of public goods -- as opposed to the plantation model used in the South and the Caribbean, which favored a small elite uninterested in representative government or widespread education. 

 The top fifth of households in the United States earn 10 times what the poorest fifth makes and more than the rest of the country combined. The incomes of the richest 1 percent are 67 times those of the poorest 20 percent of households. And over time, that gap has widened. According to theCongressional Budget Office, between 1979 and 2007, the richest 1 percent saw their after-tax incomes climb 275 percent compared with an 18 percent rise for the poorest fifth. The story is similar, if less dramatic, in other rich economies.